HOME       NORTH AMERICA       EUROPE       SOUTH AMERICA       CONTACT US       |      TAKE ACTION       DONATE       JOIN


What canned fish is best for women and children?

Canned Tuna v. Canned Salmon
The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has found the average mercury levels of canned albacore tuna to be much higher than the mercury levels of canned salmon.  Every sample of canned salmon tested by the FDA had mercury levels below the detection level of .01 parts per million, whereas the samples of canned albacore tuna it tested had an average mercury level of .353 parts per million.  In other words, FDA's tests found the average mercury level of canned albacore tuna to be at least 35 times higher than the level in canned salmon. 

Because of these levels in tuna, the Food and Drug Administration recommends that women of childbearing age and children eat no more than 6 ounces (one average meal) of albacore tuna and tuna steaks per week. 

In addition, salmon is very high in Omega-3 fatty acids.  Just one three to six ounce serving of canned salmon each week provides a whole week's worth of Omega-3's.  This is because wild salmon contains 300 to 650 mg of Omega-3 fatty acids per ounce, much more than other commonly eaten fish.  Anchovies and Atlantic mackerel are other high Omega options that are low in mercury.  Some scientists recommend consuming 250 mg of Omegas per day, an amount which is easily met by modest fish consumption in accordance with FDA's mercury advice. [1]

Many stores sell canned Alaska wild salmon in the canned fish section alongside canned tuna and many consumers have found salmon salad to be a tasty alternative to tuna salad.  In addition to lower mercury levels, another reason many consumers choose Alaska wild salmon is that it is a better option for keeping our oceans healthy.  You can find out more in our Mini-Guide to Ocean Friendly Seafood (pdf)

Albacore Tuna v. Chunk Light Tuna
If your family just can't give up its canned tuna but wants to keep mercury risks low, you can choose chunk light tuna, instead of albacore tuna.  FDA's tests have found average mercury levels in canned chunk light tuna to be about one third the average mercury levels in canned Albacore tuna (also known as solid white tuna).  Hard core tuna eaters should remember, however, that FDA recommends women of child-bearing age and kids should limit their overall fish consumption to 12 oz. per week, due to the low levels of mercury in most fish.

What's the deal with the different mercury levels?
Mercury builds up in wildlife through a process called bioaccumulation. At each level on the food chain, mercury concentrations are higher than the level below.  So since different species of fish are at different levels of the food chain, mercury concentrations differ dramatically from one species to another.

Want to help us educate the public about mercury?

Many people know that mercury in fish is a problem but don't know that there are simple steps they can take to protect their families.  A number of stores have started to post the FDA mercury advice at their seafood counters to help their customers make informed decisions, but most stores have yet to hang signs. 

Sign up to leave a comment card for your grocery store asking them to post the Food and Drug Administration mercury advice at the seafood counter. 

More Resources




[1] Mozaffarian and Rimm. 2006. Fish Intake, Contaminants, and Human Health: Evaluating the Risks and Benefits. JAMA, October 18, 2006. 296:15

Mahaffey, K.R. 2004. Fish and shellfish as dietary sources of methylmercury and the o-3 fatty acids, eicosahexaenoic acid and docosahexaenoic acid: risks and benefits. Environmental Research 95:414

 

visitor stats